In 2007, I was working as a professor at a seminary in New York City, and I was also serving a church in Greenwich Village. Out of nowhere, I had this incredible opportunity fall into my lap: I was nominated to be a young member of the French-American Foundation.
This was a relatively select group of people from the military, academia, and cultural leadership. About ten of us from the United States would meet ten leaders from France. We would spend a week in Paris and then a week somewhere in the United States to let people know about the United States.
Surprisingly, when I was given that opportunity, it took me about 30 seconds to say, “Yes, I will be a young leader in the French-American Foundation.” The time in Paris was fantastic.
Our part in the United States was in Silicon Valley. We spent five days there and went to see some of the founders of wonderful organizations like Netscape and Google. Then we went to the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.
It was there that we were going to have a private meeting with George Shultz. Shultz was the secretary of state under Ronald Reagan, a masterful statesman. In 2007, we were still enmeshed in a war in Iraq, and it was pretty amazing to sit at the feet of a statesman and hear his take on things.
As we were being moved through to the meeting place, we walked by a young woman with long blonde hair, piercing blue eyes that didn’t blink much, and red lipstick. She said in a low voice, “Welcome.” Imagine my surprise in 2014 when I looked at the cover of a magazine and saw the same young woman.
It was Elizabeth Holmes.
Such an amazing brush with fame. When I walked by her, I thought, “Is this an intern? Who is this person saying welcome?” I was amazed.
Since that brush with fame, I’ve been low-key a little bit obsessed with her story. You could see, even in that moment, that she was a brilliant strategist.
This was after she had started Theranos, the wonderful company she founded that was supposed to be able to take just a pinprick of blood and test every ill you have through her machine called the Edison. She had started that in 2003. By the time I saw her, she was looking for new board members, and the Hoover Institution was the place where she got most of her board members, including George Shultz.
After that, Theranos skyrocketed in its valuation. At one point in 2014, it was valued at between $9 billion and $10 billion. Then there were investigations, primarily by The Wall Street Journal, but also by others. Finally, the feds got involved.
By 2016, her net worth had gone from more than a billion dollars to zero. In 2022, she was convicted of wire fraud. In 2023, she started an 11-year prison sentence; she is reportedly scheduled to transfer to a halfway house in 2027.
One of the things I noticed when I was studying her work and reading through the court documents is that she was also someone who had a strong faith. She believed in God in a big way. Some of the writings sent to the court talked about her faith and asked for leniency because of it.
The crisis of how we know the truth
Recently, Elizabeth Holmes has come back into the forefront with a new documentary by Nathan Fielder called You Can See Everything. The filmmaker lived with Elizabeth and her partner, Billy Evans, for 30 days before she had to report for her prison term.
This documentary is so expertly and powerfully done that I want to encourage you all to see it. Why? Not just because I had this brush with fame, but because I’ve come to see Elizabeth Holmes as a representative figure.
There are certain people in certain times who represent everything that is going on, right and wrong, in our world. I believe she is one of those representative figures.
The documentary does an incredibly expert job of telling us how difficult it is to know exactly what happened with Elizabeth Holmes. Was she the believer who was somehow deceived by the powerful men in her life, by Sunny Balwani and then later Billy Evans, who is completely domineering? Or was she the deceiver whom these followers believed? The documentary leaves that unresolved.
Were Billy Evans or Sunny Balwani believers who believed in this person’s vision and company? Or were they deceivers, people trying to manipulate a young woman who was easily molded?
Finally, is Nathan Fielder, the documentarian, a believer in documentary as a way to uncover the truth? Or is he the master deceiver, weaving together a story based on facts that tells the story he wants to tell rather than the truth of the matter?
Elizabeth Holmes is a representative figure because we are all struggling with this idea of truth. We are all struggling with whether we can trust what is happening in our lives.
We are all facing what I would call an epistemic crisis: a crisis in which we do not know exactly how to tell truth from fiction in our world. It is cutting across our culture and making us miserable.
Who is the believer, and who is the deceiver?
In our context, in our world, it is impossible to know. The usual ways in which we talk about and discover the truth do not work in and of themselves.
Some people say that what is true is what is factual, what we can know perfectly. “This pillar is made out of stone” is a fact. But the facts of the matter are never quite as they appear. Right behind this pillar is not limestone; there is actually a steel bar and brick. The beautiful limestone is a veneer.
Others would say that truth is what holds together in a comprehensive whole: something logical, consistent, coherent. But we have the possibility and power within ourselves to create belief systems that are networked and powerful. These are the bubbles and echo chambers we create through social media.
There are those who will tell you that truth is found in the sincerity of the truth speaker. But deceivers can feel deeply, strongly, powerfully, emotionally that their version of events is the truth.
We are facing a crisis over how we know the truth. It is cutting across every part of our society, and it is making us miserable.
Truth and the Beatitudes
All of this is important for us to name because Christianity is not based on a theory of truth. Christianity does not make a strong claim about the facts at play. Christianity does not claim to have a comprehensive vision without any interruption or misinterpretation. Christianity does not even claim that if you believe with all your heart, soul, and mind, you are good with God.
What Christianity stands or falls on is whether we see, in our truth, God’s truth as revealed by Jesus. The core claim of truth in Christianity is the revelation of Jesus Christ. He is our truth.
As we read in the Gospel of John, Jesus himself says, “I am the way, the truth, and the life.” All that we know, all that we can claim, all that we can trust in this world and call true is revealed by Jesus.
That means we find the truth in relationship with God. That is why worship is so important. Worship is not helping you find your way to the truth. Worship tells you that when you are in right relationship with God, truth is revealed to you as you sit at the feet of the God who made you, loved you, and redeemed you in Jesus Christ.
That is why we have, in our first reading from Revelation, that beautiful, wonderful, worshipful moment:
“Amen, blessing and glory and wisdom and thanksgiving and honor and power and might be to our God forever and ever.”
Look at that word “wisdom.” Truth is found in worship. Truth is found in relationship. Truth comes from Jesus Christ.
We also see it in our reading from 1 John, in which we are told that, in this deep relationship with Jesus, we have been given the power to become the children of God. Our truth is found in becoming part of God’s own family.
Most importantly, it is revealed in our reading from the Beatitudes:
When Jesus says,
“Blessed are the poor in spirit.”
When Jesus says,
“Blessed are you who mourn.”
When Jesus says,
“Blessed are you who hunger and thirst for righteousness.”
Jesus is speaking a truth about who we are.
We cannot find our way to God simply through being poor or poor in spirit. We cannot find our way to God in the midst of mourning because, when we are mourning, we are eaten alive with our grief. We cannot find our way to God. God must be revealed to us in those moments.
The Beatitudes are a kind of truth. They are a claim upon us in the name of Jesus. They point us not only to the name of Jesus, which is to be magnified, but also to the teachings of Jesus, which make us whole.
We see this primarily in that wonderful word “blessed,” the Greek of which is makarios. It means not just blessed in the sense that God sees when no one else sees. It means that we are wise and powerful when we understand that God is with those who are poor, with those who are mourning, with those who will speak their truth and suffer the consequences.
Makarios: the better translation of that is “flourishing.” Today’s Gospel is an invitation to find our truth in Jesus and to find that truth as it is revealed in the Beatitudes.
This is work we need to do desperately. It is work we need now because we do not know how to trust or find the truth of anything.
What it means to follow Jesus
There are three things I want to lift up about what it means to follow Jesus and to find ourselves in the truth revealed in the Beatitudes. What I want to make sure you understand is that the Beatitudes are a kind of mirror of both Jesus and us.
The Beatitudes are a mirror because, when we look at them, we see the face of Christ. We see Jesus through his teachings.
The Beatitudes are also a mirror of us. In this world, where everybody is vying for our attention and we are pulled in different directions, the only way we know who we are is by looking at ourselves in the mirror of the promises of God made in them.
The first way I want you to see the Beatitudes goes with the earliest grain of the Christian tradition: they are a revelation from above. There is a strong belief that, when Jesus sat down on that mountain and called his disciples to him, he was stepping into the place of Moses.
Just as Moses gave the Ten Commandments, Jesus was giving the Beatitudes. This was to be our law. This was going to be the way we could see God.
That is a powerful idea that inspired the founders of this country. In the earliest strata of the writings of the colonists, the Beatitudes had a central place.
This was revived by Ronald Reagan when he was leaving office. His farewell speech invoked the Sermon on the Mount’s image of a city on a hill. That image appears two verses after the end of the Gospel reading.
Tip O’Neill, Ronald Reagan’s great adversary from the Democratic Party and the Speaker of the House, called the Beatitudes “the best political speech ever given.” The proper government should try to make possible everything promised by Jesus.
The fact that these two leaders cited the Sermon on the Mount and the Beatitudes in their lives is an indication of who we might be and who we are called to be as a community and as a country. I miss that America. I miss the America that had that common language of the Beatitudes, that held us together. I invite you to think of that America when you make your decisions.
The second thing I want to lift up is that the Beatitudes are a revelation from beyond. They are a revelation of what is coming to be through God’s salvation of the world in Jesus.
The Beatitudes speak of a world being brought into existence through death and resurrection. It is not something we can earn, manage, or find. The Beatitudes find us when the Spirit of God lives in us.
That is what it means to flourish when you reach out and hold on to God with all your might. When you decide, “This is going to be my God,” that is not just you making a decision. That is the Spirit of God living in you.
There is something powerful about this promise from the future coming into our present. There is a reason we read this passage on All Saints’ Day.
When we hear that we have been blessed in the midst of our mourning, those of us experiencing profound grief can have the incredible comfort of knowing that Jesus has revealed himself in these moments when we grieve. Jesus has called the time of grief blessed, which is another way of saying that he is present with us now.
The final way I want to lift up the Beatitudes is as a revelation from below. By that I mean the Beatitudes come to be when you and I, in our lives, extend ourselves into this world.
When we choose to turn the other cheek, when we choose to forgive, to love, to sacrifice; when we choose not only to meet the poor but to be with the poor and address the poor; when we can admit that we have also become spiritually bankrupt and are poor in spirit ourselves: in those moments, we are entering into that space of flourishing. We are starting to participate in the change Jesus is working in this world day by day.
On this day, with these beautiful words, may we find in Jesus our truth. May we find, in the life we share in relationship to God through worship and work, a powerful way of being in the world and knowing what we can trust.
May we find in our work together a vision of our life together, and bear witness to those guiding values and aspirational goods that have made this country good.
May we find, in that promise coming to us from beyond, a promise we can lean into in the midst of our grief, our pain, and our suffering: that God is with us and redeeming us.
May we take one step closer to that flourishing which Jesus promises us each day.
Amen.
