I have been a priest for more than 30 years. I was ordained in my late twenties, and I spent a lot of my time as a priest in different places. One of my favorite places where I had a posting was in New York City in the late 1990s. I was about three years into being a priest. When you are at a church in Greenwich Village, you develop an incredible database of people who come in. So many people would come into that church out of nowhere, looking for strong medicine.
This was back in the late nineties, when Greenwich Village was Greenwich Village. It wasn’t the gated community it has become. It was a place where there was a lot of action and a lot of temptation, where a lot of things were done and said. People would come in wanting to be right with God. They had enough of whatever they had been doing, and they would come in looking for some kind of new life in their life.
One of my favorite people who came in, whom I think about constantly and pray about, was a businessman named Ira. He came in off the street, and he was amazing. He had a beautiful power suit on. I am talking about the suits from the late 1990s—an incredible suit of armor made of felt and wool. Suits these days are not the same; the suits that young men wear today look like they are about three sizes too small. Not Ira’s suit. Ira’s suit was beautiful, and the tie was fantastic as well.
He sat in my office and began to bellow out the f-bomb loudly. I don’t want to say it because there are young ears, but he would shout it, cover his mouth, and weep. Then he would say it again. People got a little bit concerned because he was shouting so loudly. Staff would cross in front of my door and peek in, and I would say, “It’s okay. It’s okay.”
After about 20 or 30 minutes, and I am not making this up, he said to me, “I have been struggling my entire life with deep loneliness and feeling rootless and without any kind of faith, and I am ready to make a change in my life. I am ready to be changed. I have been walking past this church for years, and I just had this feeling that this is where I needed to be.”
So I said, “Well, Ira, this is what we do in the Christian faith. We get baptized. We turn away from everything that is drawing us away from God. We renounce sin, death, and the devil, and we turn and accept Jesus as our life giver, our liberator, and our Lord. That’s what you do at baptism. Do you want to do that?”
He said, “Yes.”
On the day he was baptized, his family didn’t show. He was alone. My little community in Greenwich Village immediately jumped up, sponsored him, answered for him, and supported him as he made this life-changing decision.
What is an idol?
I will never forget the moment when I realized that Ira’s search for God was incredibly powerful. I was teaching the adult baptism class, and we had about six people there who were trying to get their lives together with God. The others looked like they were about to start a band in their garage in Seattle. Then there was Ira, in a beautiful suit on a Sunday.
I tried to get some interaction going between them, so I asked, “What draws you from the love of God?”
Someone raised their hand and said, “Sex.”
I said, “Okay.” I grabbed my dry-erase marker, reached over, wrote “sex” on the board, and asked, “What else?”
Someone said, “Drugs.”
I said, “Okay, right, we’re cooking. Drugs. What else?”
Then someone, of course, said, “Rock and roll.” I turned around and wrote “rock and roll.”
Ira became impatient with this. He raised his hand and said, “I’m sorry, I disagree.”
I said, “Tell me, why do you disagree?”
He said, “I don’t think that any of those things are sin, or even evil, or from the devil. I don’t think sex is a sin. I don’t think drugs are sinful. I don’t think rock and roll—certainly not rock and roll—is sinful. It’s when those things become a god to me that they become sin to me. It’s when those things claim me. I have spent my life following those things, and I have found myself empty. What I need to do is reject those things as the idols they are.”
As soon as he said that, I realized how powerful his search for God was, and how powerful his insight was. Because truly, that is the case. There is nothing wrong with sex. There is nothing wrong with drugs. There is nothing wrong with rock and roll. But for all of us, when we turn away from the things that draw us from the love of God and turn toward Jesus, there is a step we have to take. That step is to reject the power that idols have in our life.
What is an idol?
Martin Luther, the great Christian reformer, writes in his Large Catechism that if you want to know what an idol is, just ask yourself what your heart desires most. That will be your god or your idol. Idols are, for Luther, the generation of our desires. For others, idols are things that completely destroy our humanity. When we worship an idol, we are worshiping only a part rather than the whole. We are worshiping something that should be a path on the way to the end—a means to an end rather than the end itself
What is an idol?
Everything in Christianity turns on our ability to name the idols in our life and to reject them—to name them, to unmask them, to resist them, and to claim a living relationship with God.
Rejecting the things that stand in the place of God
All of our readings for today, in one way or another, speak about this fundamental claim that God makes upon us, a claim that expects us to reject the things that stand in the place of God. That is what an idol is.
In our reading from Isaiah, in the midst of telling the people of Israel that he is going to send an appointed leader through the Persians to bring them back to the promised land, God says to them, “I am the Lord, and there is no other; besides me there is no god.” In our Psalm, Psalm 96, you find: “For all the gods of the peoples are idols, but the Lord made the heavens.” In our reading from 1 Thessalonians, you have this beautiful line where Paul commends the Thessalonians because they have “turned to God from idols to serve a living and true God.”
That turn from idolatry goes with the grain of our Judeo-Christian tradition. It is the fundamental insight. In today’s Gospel, idolatry is at the crux of things. If you miss it, you miss everything in this Gospel passage.
Why? Because you have perhaps heard people tell you what this Gospel means. There are people who will tell you that when Jesus said, “Give therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s,” he was making a neat division that allows us to live our lives the way we want to live them: you have to give some money to Caesar, and you have to give some money to God. Oftentimes I have heard this—maybe you have too—couched in terms of giving money to the church.
But that is not what this Gospel is about. It has nothing to do with dividing up your life into the things you owe one party and not another.
The key to the passage happens in the moment when Jesus asks them what is on the coin they are holding in their hand, the denarius. He asks them:
“Whose head is this, and whose title?”
I have given you an example of that coin—not the exact same coin, but the mint of it—above. It is a denarius forged somewhere between the years 18 and 35 in Lyon, France, and this was the only coin you could use to pay taxes to the emperor. On that coin, the inscription and title read:
“Tiberius Caesar, son of the divine Augustus.”
That coin they produced for Jesus as an example of what it means to pay taxes to the emperor is, in other words, the very definition of an idol. It is a total claim. The people who hold that coin and give that coin are acknowledging that the empire and the emperor are divinely instituted and are of God.
When Jesus calls them on this (and he is right to call them on this, because they should not have been carrying that in the temple where they were meeting) Jesus is showing them that they were carrying that little bit of idolatry right into the temple. If they had been truly faithful, they would have exchanged the money outside the temple for a shekel, not a denarius.
Jesus is inviting his listeners—both the Pharisees and the Herodians, and us as his listeners—to understand what it means to be enslaved to an idol. It is not just treating something subordinate as the end. It is not just running away with our desires. Idols have a power in our lives, and it all has to be named, unmasked, and resisted.
Three things that idols do to us
What is an idol? There are three things I want to lift up in this Gospel that you need to see.
The first thing an idol does in your life is limit you, bifurcate you, and divide you, creating a binary between what is right and what is wrong. Everything else in the Scriptures points to the fact that creation is good and is called to relationship with God. In Psalm 24, “The earth is the Lord’s and all that is in it.” But an idol will claim one part, and that part will pretend to be the whole.
Second, idols can be the manifestation of great desires, but they can also be the manifestation of great fears. That is because idol worship is contagious. When someone is held captive to an idol—whether it be propriety, status, achievement, your place in the community, whether or not you get into a country club, or whatever you do to create a hierarchy within your life—that is often not just an exercise in desire. It is that you have seen this is something others want, and you are held captive by it. That captivity is as much a product of fear as it is of love or desire.
Finally, and most importantly, Jesus invites his listeners to see that when you give your life to God, you find your full humanity. Idols always rob us of our humanity. When we are in right relationship with God, we find the humanity Jesus has prepared for us—a humanity that is full, whole, and in right relationship with God.
Active and spiritual stewardship
All of these things are important for us to consider at this time and in this place. Yes, we are in the midst of a season in which we are making appeals to you, as humbly as we know how, to tell the story of how many of us have come to this church and have been transformed by it. We want you to fall in love with that story. We want you to see that in the self-offering of those stories, there is an image for your own path to giving to this church.
But this is not simply an appeal to you for funds. We want you to be transformed spiritually by this whole process we call stewardship. This process is meant to be a way for you to be transformed. Having been a priest for more than 30 years, I will stand by that spiritual invitation before anything else.
If there is anything in you that is responding to the power of an idol in your life when you are giving to this church, I don’t want you to give the money. If this gift is part of your transformation, if this gift is part of you claiming the humanity that is yours, if this gift is you believing in everything we are doing as a church, then bring it on, and be transformed by the gift you give.

The first step in any active stewardship isn’t finding out how much you can give. It isn’t figuring out whether or not the church deserves it. It’s prayer. I am inviting you to pray with me, and to be changed over the next few weeks as we think together about all the stories of redemption. Since coming here, I have seen many more stories than Ira’s. His story is powerful, but so are yours.
Recognizing my own struggles with idolatry
To help us make a start with this, I am going to share with you a poem that I wrote—a poem of self-dedication and a recognition of my own struggles with idolatry:
When I made you into something I could hold in my hands, you refused to be held.
Slipping my grasp, you held me with your mercy.
When I tried to earn your acceptance, you left me with silence.
Ignoring my ambition, you asked only for my heart.
When I walked the labyrinth of my desires, you led me in circles,
waiting for my restlessness to end in surrender.
When I filled myself with knowledge, you covered yourself in mystery,
waiting to fill my emptiness with your love.
When I ran into the darkness, your light shined on my back,
waiting for me to show you my face.
When I sacrificed my life on countless altars, you refused my offering,
waiting until I had nothing left to give but myself.
You are a God who waits.
So that lost, I might find you.
Exhausted, I might rest in you.
Empty, I might be filled with you.
Broken, I might learn compassion.
Reconciled, I might be made new.
“Give to God the things that are God’s,” says Jesus.
This requires of us, first and foremost, an attitude of prayer. It requires an understanding that stepping into relationship with a living God is something that calls all of us—no matter where we are, no matter who we are—into a relationship of transformation.
May that be so for you today and always.
Amen.

